Tuesday, May 14, 2013

Very Sad, Disappointing News....



With a heavy heart I write this blog post.....

Fritzy and I a few years ago.

I had been preparing myself for a worst case outcome on our Paint mare, Fritzy. And I sure am glad I did....

After almost 8 months of stall rest, I had another vet come out and take digital X-rays of Fritzy's hoof. She just had not been showing any signs of improvement, in all actuality she got worse for a time, until we found out that the bar shoe was causing her hoof to grow long, narrow and she was sitting down on her heel. So we changed her shoeing, which relieved the pressure on her foot and helped her to be more comfortable just standing in her stall.


Fritzy and I on a trail ride about 5 years ago.

The digital X-rays taken today confirmed that there is definitely something seriously wrong with Fritzy's hoof. Back in September and even as most recently as a month ago, my regular vet had taken X-rays, but not digital (she does not own digital X-ray equipment.) That diagnosis from her and a surgeon from a local Veterinary Hospital saw what was a coffin bone fracture, but it wasn't conclusive. So they recommended that we treat her as if she had a CB fracture, which meant putting a bar shoe on with 3 clips on each side to prevent her hoof from expanding. Basically it acts like a cast and holds the CB in place to give the CB time to heal. Plus she was to be on stall rest for at least 6 months with absolutely no hand walking. I followed the vet's instructions with absolutely no deviations. I wanted to make sure that Frtizy healed and we didn't have any major setbacks. 


So today when the vet showed me on the computer the digital X-rays of Fritzy's hoof and what she found....... I was so disappointed. Now, I can't talk vet lingo very well, but I will explain to the best of my abilities what is going on. She did not find any sign of a CB fracture, but that does not mean there was not one there and that it had healed. But what she did find in the same general area, but not in the exact same area where the fracture showed up on the other X-rays, was what she called bone lysis, which is an area of reduced bone density, on the lateral side of the coffin bone wing. So in normal person language, there is bone loss in the CB wing. Which would definitely make her as lame as she has been. Now what causes bone loss? Well, it could be a couple different things. One, since she is prone to hoof abscesses, there could have been an abscess that went into the bone and got infected and basically it degenerates the bone, hopefully I explained that right, I am not a hoof expert by any means. Second, she could have bruised her foot and that could have caused internal issues with her hoof.


So, what do we do from here? Well, first thing is that my farrier will be coming out and putting a normal shoe with thick pad back on her and we will turn her out to pasture. Yes, stall rest is over. It isn't doing her any good standing around in a stall when she does not need to be in a stall anymore. Being in a stall isn't going to make her hoof heal, because it can't. And being turned out on pasture isn't going to make it any worse, I mean it is already bad, how much worse can it get? So why not let the lame horse enjoy being an actual horse for the first time in 8 months? But that is NOT good news. 


Because the chances of Fritzy ever being a sound, rideable horse EVER again is slim to none. Yep. My horse is done.


My OH and his beloved girl, Fritzy.

And the reason being that she will never be a sound or rideable horse again is because you can't make bone grow back. So the bone loss in her CB is gone for good. Which means she will be lame forever. Now that is not saying that she won't or can't improve, but the vet told me she hasn't seen a case like Fritzy's ever turn into a 100% sound horse. There are a couple treatment options, one being a drug called Tildren. But she did not recommend it, first it is super expensive and second, there are absolutely no guarantees that it will work. The other option she said was we could do is a permanent nerve block, which permanently blocks all feeling from that area of her hoof. Now I do not like the sound of that, my farrier even told me that isn't a good idea because the horse can't feel if they are landing right and can injure themselves even more then what they already are. So I am pretty much out of options. This vet is going to send the digital X-rays to the same Doctor at the Vet Hospital who helped my other vet with the original diagnosis. So he may have other treatment ideas or know something else we could possibly do. But for now..........

I will never look through these ears again.



39 comments:

L.Williams said...

I am so sorry, I am in a very similar boat. My horse was essentially diagnosed with massive bone loss in the Navicular, its extremely bad to the point I shouldn't ride him and he can't go out and we are set to put him down later this month. If your horses case isn't beyond hope you can try Tildren which is expensive but has been proven to be very good.

Lauren @ She Moved To Texas said...

:( I'm really sorry to hear this. That is not an easy thing to take or know what to do with. Good vibes for you while dealing with this.

Unknown said...

Oh that sucks! I was really hoping she was going to be one of the success stories. I feel your pain, as you know we are still dealing with Sassy's mystery lameness as well.

I wonder how Fritzy would do in boots with comfort padding to give her some relief? Just a thought.

in2paints said...

I'm so sorry to hear this!! I was hoping the stall rest would do the trick. On one hand, it's good that you finally have a better idea of what's going on, but now you also know how bad it is. I'm sure Fritzy will be SUPER happy to be outside and I'll be sending good thoughts to you both that there's an option out there that will work for her.

She's such a gorgeous girl!!

C-ingspots said...

Oh I'm so sorry to hear this! Just sucks...this is very similar to what I'm dealing with in my newest horse, Sugar. Navicular case with bone loss. She has what they call a bone cyst, which is basically a hole in the navicular bone. If you can afford Tildren, it does work. We've used it on several horses with bone loss, but it works best when it's used systemically meaning 10 vials at once. They can also use less, 1 or 2 vials injected into the foot itself with the help of a tourniquet. Cheaper, but not as effective. If you know of a vet in Canada who could send you the drug, it would be way cheaper. Here in the States we have to go through US Customs and have it shipped in from France. Yes, it's expensive. Lots of paperwork, it's a pain, but it might be worth a shot. You'd probably pay at least $2000 for a one-time treatment (10 vials)as a rough estimate. But the stuff is amazing and helps if the bone loss isn't too extensive. Hopefully, Fritzy will enjoy her newly found freedom and you can still enjoy her company for years to come, if nothing else.

hg said...

I'm so very sorry.... I know your pain.

Sherry Sikstrom said...

so sorry to read this,m she is a lovely mare and I, as did so many had hoped for a positive outcome. Hugs

lytha said...

i found myself praying for fritzi this morning, praying for a miracle. i want your husband to be able to ride her again. i also know that lame horses can have good quality of life in a pasture.

Anonymous said...

I am so sorry - it's hard to find that all the work you've done to try to make things better didn't get you or her where you wanted to be. I'm just glad that she gets to enjoy being in the pasture again, and hope that you'll be able to keep her comfortable there - if she can still be a horse and enjoy life that's not a bad outcome - at least from her point of view.

JJ said...

I'm truly sorry to read this news about sweet Fritzy. I wish I had words to send you comfort :( Bit huge hugs to you and Fritz!

BrownEyed Cowgirl said...

I am so very sorry that the diagnosis is so grim.

Reddunappy said...

Dang it! You have done your best to get her to heal. So sorry. You did a good job explaining what is going on. It is amazing how fragile these big animals are.

Crystal said...

So sorry to hear this. I sure was hoping for the best and wanted her to make a full recovery, or at least riding sound.

Laura said...

I'm so sorry to hear that news.

:-(

baystatebrumby said...

But can you still keep her and have her around? Because that does not sound so bad--having a horse doing her own thing and living an fine life walking around, investigating things and nibbling hay! Of course if she is in pain, that is another story altogether. I am crushed for her. It certainly is a game changer. I am glad to hear the stall rest is over! That is a very liberating (and therefore happy) moment.

Paint Girl said...

Yes, we are still going to keep her. We will see how she does with turnout and if she shows any signs of improvement. But with the bone loss there probably won't be any improvement and most likely will get worse. She is very lame and it hurts me just watching her walk. She wasn't lame at the walk 8 months ago and the bone loss has gotten worse during the time she has been on stall rest. We will monitor her closely and if we feel that she is in too much pain down the road we might have to make that very difficult decision. I am hoping that day doesn't come, but she's only 14 years old and I just can't see her living another 10-15 years like this. :(

cdncowgirl said...

I really wish there had been better news :(

sally said...

Geez I don't know what to say .....heart breaking to say the least.Hopefully she isn't in too much pain and can enjoy being a beautiful companion.Who knows.....a summer evening to simply sit on her back in the field and still look through those ears

Nicki said...

Sorry-hope you can at least keep her comfortable. Ask your vet about using dog Previcox on her. I know it sucks but hopefully she can still be a pet for a long time. Hang in there.

Paint Girl said...

I am so sorry to hear about your horse. So very sad. My thoughts are with you!!

Paint Girl said...

Thank you Lauren! Appreciate it!

Paint Girl said...

I know Cindy, I was really hoping that too. Unfortunately that's not the case :( My farrier put on a regular plate shoe with a hard pad and some soft filling inside so dirt and rocks can't get inside. I don't think boots will help. She is so lame. :(

Paint Girl said...

Thank you! Right now I have been hand walking her and letting her graze. I did turn her loose the other day to clean her stall and after 8 months of stall rest, she just walked around and ate! I think the green grass kept her mentally sane!! After she gets accustomed to the grass, I will turn her out permanently.

Paint Girl said...

Thank you! I am so sorry to hear about Sugar! It is so hard to go through these kind of situations. We all just want was is best for our horses. I am still waiting to hear back from the surgeon from the vet hospital. So maybe he can give me some more input on the situation.

Paint Girl said...

Thank you!

Paint Girl said...

Thanks so much Sherry!! I appreciate it!!

Paint Girl said...

Oh Lytha!! You are so sweet! My heart still goes out to you after losing your beautiful Baasha!! It is not easy and I so hope I don't have to make that decision anytime soon!! Only positive thoughts here on our end. I would love for my OH to be able to ride her again. He absolutely loves and adores her!

Paint Girl said...

Thank you Kate! We are slowly getting her used to being back out on grass before we turn her out. I really am hoping that her moving around, getting the blood flowing back in her feet will help. It worries me so much that how lame she is that being a pasture pet will still be too painful. We will keep a very close eye on her. :(

Paint Girl said...

Thank you JJ!! That means a lot!

Paint Girl said...

Me too BEC!! I was so hoping for better news, but had prepared myself for bad news. I just had a feeling though that it wasn't going to be good. Dang it.

Paint Girl said...

Isn't that the truth! So very big, yet so very fragile. It is so unfortunate. It's been a very tough week. :(

Paint Girl said...

Me too Crystal! I was hoping that we could get her sound enough for short trail rides, unfortunately that will not be the case. Very sad. Thank you!

Paint Girl said...

Thank you Laura!

Paint Girl said...

I do too! That is my worst fear, that we won't be able to keep her comfortable. But we have discussed what we will need to do if that is not the case. But we are trying to stay positive that she can live a happy life at pasture, hopefully not in much pain.

Paint Girl said...

Thanks Lisa! So do we. Even though we prepared ourselves, it still hits pretty dang hard. I still tear up and every time I look at pictures riding her, I cry. Even though we didn't get along like my other horses, she has to be the sweetest horse (in her own way, lol!) She is my OH's princess, ya know! Lol!

Paint Girl said...

Thanks Sally! That sounds like a really great idea, sitting on her back while she is grazing... I will have to do that this summer!

Paint Girl said...

Thanks Nicki! I will have to check that out. I am hoping she can be a pet for many years to come too! That is our hope!!

SquirrelGurl said...

Your last picture made me tear up, I posted a similar one a couple of years ago when I realized my horse Buttercup was going blind. It's a harsh realization that your partner who was in their prime suddenly isn't anymore. I know exactly how you feel.

We too made the decision to keep our girl around as long as she is comfortable. I look at old pictures and videos and cry sometimes. But, I tell myself that I still get quality time with her, it's just not time in the saddle.

Achieve1dream said...

I'm so, so sorry for the bad news. Not being able to ride her is bad enough, but that's not the end of the world. Her potentially being in so much pain that you'd have to euthanize is just so completely heartbreaking. I'm so, so sorry. I'll pray for her that the movement will improve her lameness so that she can be a content pasture puff. Hang in there!